In unserer Liquid Feedback Instanz wurde Thema 1989 abgestimmt. Diese Seite soll das Abstimmungsergebnis näher erklären.

Hinweis

  • Diese Seite hat zwei Ziele:
    1. Zum einen soll sie eine unabhängige und nachprüfbare Instanz sein, bei der die Ergebnisse von Liquid Feedback selbstständig aus den Abstimmungsdaten berechnet werden können, damit kein Vertrauen in diesen Aspekt von Liquid Feedback notwendig ist.
    2. Zum anderen soll das Abstimmungsergebnis möglichst verständlich aufbereitet werden und am konkreten Beispiel die benutzten Verfahren erklären.
  • Diese Aufbereitung ist noch in einem frühen Stadium. Weder die Erklärungen noch die Berechnungen sind vollständig zufriedenstellend. Für konstruktive Hinweise per Mail an niels.lohmann@piraten-mv.de freue ich mich sehr.
  • Die Reiter „Rohdaten“ und „Quelle“ sollen in Zukunft beschreiben, wie man an die hier aufbereiteten Daten und Ergebnisse kommen kann. Eine genauere Beschreibung sowie eine Veröffentlichung des Scriptes, das diese Seiten erstellt, steht noch aus.
  • Die hier gezeigte Umsetzung der Schulze-Methode entspricht nicht den in den jeweiligen Wikipedia-Artikeln beschrieben Verfahren, wo bei der Bestimmung der stärksten Wege ein anderer Vergleichsoperator genutzt wird. Eine genauere Beschreibung der Unterschiede steht aus. Mehr Details lassen sich auf der LQFB-Website bzw. gleich im Paper von Markus Schulze finden.
  • Die hier gezeigte Umsetzung der Schulze-Methode entspricht nicht vollständig dem in Liquid Feedback verwendeten Verfahren. Es ist also durchaus möglich (und bekannt), dass die hier beschriebenen Abstimmungsergebnisse nicht notwendigerweise mit denen in Liquid Feedback übereinstimmen. Ich stehe mit den Entwicklern in Kontakt, um dies zu ändern. Insbesondere verwendet Liquid Feedback ein Verfahren um stets eine vollständige Ordnung (statt nur einer Halbordnung) zu erreichen. Da die zuerst verwendete Umsetzung einen Fehler hatte und die nun verwendete Umsetzung undemokratisch ist (d.h. die Initiative mit der geringsten Id bevorzugt), habe ich mich dazu entschlossen, abzuwarten wie dieses Problem gelöst wird.
  • Definitiv in Planung ist ein Vergleich des Endergebnisses mit den abgegebenen Stimmen. Vielleicht lässt sich quantifizieren, inwieweit das Abstimmungsergebnis den Mehrheitswillen abbildet. Ebenso wäre es wünschenswert, weitere Eigenschaften des Wahlverfahrens (z.B. Clone-Proofness) zu beschreiben.

Initiativen

Es standen 2 Initiativen im Bereich Umwelt, Verkehr, Energie zur Abstimmung:

Im folgenden werden die Initiativen nur noch mit ihrer Nummer beschrieben.

SELECT area_id, fully_frozen, closed FROM issue WHERE (id = '1989') ORDER BY id
SELECT name FROM area WHERE (id = 6) ORDER BY id
SELECT id, name FROM initiative WHERE (issue_id = '1989' AND admitted = true) ORDER BY id
issue
Groups of initiatives
area
Subject areas
initiative
Group of members publishing drafts for resolutions to be passed; Frontends must ensure that initiatives of half_frozen issues are not revoked, and that initiatives of fully_frozen or closed issues are neither revoked nor created.
(6, datetime.datetime(2012, 7, 3, 22, 56, 46, 586782, tzinfo=psycopg2.tz.FixedOffsetTimezone(offset=120, name=None)), datetime.datetime(2012, 7, 11, 23, 8, 22, 286882, tzinfo=psycopg2.tz.FixedOffsetTimezone(offset=120, name=None)))
('Umwelt, Verkehr, Energie',)
(3531, 'Einf\xc3\xbchrung generelles Tempolimit')
(3584, 'Neue Tempolimits auf Stra\xc3\x9fen')

Abstimmung

Die Abstimmung fand von Dienstag, den 03. Juli 2012 bis Mittwoch, den 11. Juli 2012 statt.

Es haben 490 Mitglieder mit insgesamt 746 Stimmen abgestimmt.

Falls es mehr Stimmen als Mitglieder gibt, entstammen die zusätzlichen Stimmen Delegationen. Falls ein Mitglied beispielsweise mit zwei eingehenden Delegationen abgestimmt hat, wird dies im folgenden wie zwei zusätzliche gleiche abgegebene Stimmen behandelt.

SELECT member_id, weight FROM direct_voter WHERE (issue_id = '1989')
direct_voter
Members having directly voted for/against initiatives of an issue; Frontends must ensure that no voters are added or removed to/from this table when the issue has been closed.
(64, 2)
(76, 10)
(86, 2)
(120, 7)
(126, 1)
(128, 2)
(183, 1)
(191, 1)
(220, 1)
(231, 6)
(249, 1)
(254, 1)
(276, 3)
(309, 1)
(382, 1)
(401, 1)
(447, 1)
(458, 1)
(468, 2)
(531, 1)
(536, 1)
(552, 4)
(561, 1)
(573, 1)
(588, 67)
(600, 4)
(618, 1)
(631, 1)
(668, 1)
(680, 1)
(688, 1)
(807, 1)
(831, 1)
(898, 33)
(907, 1)
(926, 37)
(1014, 2)
(1034, 1)
(1049, 1)
(1104, 1)
(1220, 1)
(1222, 1)
(1238, 2)
(1239, 1)
(1244, 1)
(1259, 2)
(1294, 1)
(1346, 1)
(1369, 1)
(1430, 13)
(1452, 1)
(1494, 1)
(1600, 1)
(1606, 1)
(1609, 1)
(1613, 1)
(1634, 1)
(1642, 1)
(1681, 1)
(1694, 1)
(1722, 1)
(1723, 2)
(1753, 2)
(1812, 1)
(1815, 1)
(1867, 1)
(1900, 2)
(1907, 1)
(1958, 1)
(1987, 1)
(2100, 7)
(2172, 1)
(2201, 1)
(2327, 1)
(2328, 1)
(2394, 2)
(2407, 1)
(2417, 10)
(2446, 1)
(2458, 9)
(2481, 1)
(2486, 1)
(2543, 10)
(2544, 2)
(2552, 1)
(2574, 1)
(2584, 1)
(2608, 1)
(2648, 1)
(2709, 3)
(2763, 1)
(2820, 2)
(2850, 1)
(2886, 1)
(2908, 1)
(2958, 6)
(3022, 5)
(3040, 1)
(3049, 1)
(3078, 1)
(3095, 1)
(3099, 1)
(3117, 1)
(3146, 1)
(3175, 2)
(3205, 1)
(3329, 1)
(3341, 1)
(3418, 2)
(3428, 1)
(3430, 1)
(3450, 1)
(3487, 1)
(3501, 1)
(3562, 1)
(3571, 1)
(3580, 1)
(3652, 1)
(3705, 1)
(3730, 1)
(3778, 1)
(3793, 11)
(3819, 1)
(3854, 1)
(3859, 2)
(3873, 1)
(3885, 1)
(3953, 1)
(3957, 1)
(4020, 1)
(4052, 2)
(4064, 1)
(4080, 1)
(4081, 3)
(4089, 1)
(4107, 1)
(4221, 1)
(4232, 2)
(4233, 1)
(4252, 1)
(4322, 1)
(4348, 1)
(4365, 1)
(4366, 1)
(4370, 1)
(4416, 1)
(4456, 1)
(4459, 1)
(4489, 1)
(4499, 1)
(4510, 1)
(4539, 1)
(4542, 1)
(4559, 1)
(4600, 1)
(4602, 1)
(4645, 1)
(4646, 1)
(4652, 1)
(4722, 1)
(4724, 2)
(4788, 1)
(4814, 1)
(4865, 1)
(4874, 1)
(4949, 1)
(4956, 1)
(5107, 1)
(5141, 1)
(5185, 1)
(5248, 1)
(5253, 1)
(5293, 1)
(5335, 1)
(5351, 1)
(5380, 3)
(5427, 1)
(5480, 1)
(5523, 1)
(5581, 1)
(5612, 1)
(5638, 1)
(5850, 1)
(5852, 1)
(5909, 1)
(5995, 1)
(6000, 1)
(6002, 1)
(6013, 1)
(6056, 1)
(6094, 1)
(6129, 1)
(6167, 2)
(6200, 1)
(6252, 1)
(6257, 1)
(6295, 1)
(6326, 1)
(6375, 1)
(6386, 1)
(6387, 1)
(6395, 1)
(6417, 1)
(6448, 1)
(6461, 2)
(6468, 1)
(6516, 1)
(6571, 1)
(6644, 1)
(6649, 1)
(6653, 1)
(6755, 1)
(6787, 1)
(6789, 2)
(6798, 1)
(6810, 1)
(6842, 1)
(6868, 1)
(7053, 1)
(7098, 1)
(7190, 1)
(7207, 1)
(7214, 1)
(7225, 1)
(7246, 1)
(7300, 1)
(7338, 1)
(7361, 1)
(7378, 1)
(7408, 1)
(7416, 1)
(7420, 1)
(7437, 1)
(7453, 1)
(7462, 1)
(7525, 1)
(7539, 1)
(7561, 1)
(7570, 1)
(7658, 1)
(7662, 1)
(7724, 1)
(7753, 1)
(7824, 1)
(7828, 1)
(7840, 1)
(7908, 1)
(7913, 1)
(7916, 1)
(8052, 1)
(8054, 1)
(8074, 1)
(8106, 1)
(8107, 1)
(8110, 1)
(8114, 1)
(8152, 1)
(8172, 1)
(8180, 1)
(8193, 1)
(8210, 1)
(8373, 1)
(8391, 1)
(8406, 1)
(8436, 1)
(8488, 1)
(8501, 1)
(8521, 1)
(8541, 1)
(8548, 1)
(8568, 1)
(8580, 1)
(8602, 1)
(8604, 1)
(8605, 1)
(8617, 1)
(8620, 1)
(8632, 1)
(8647, 1)
(8651, 1)
(8663, 1)
(8668, 1)
(8686, 1)
(8692, 1)
(8717, 1)
(8725, 1)
(8728, 1)
(8734, 1)
(8738, 1)
(8758, 1)
(8765, 1)
(8781, 1)
(8836, 1)
(8839, 1)
(8855, 1)
(8869, 1)
(8875, 1)
(8886, 1)
(8890, 1)
(8906, 1)
(8913, 1)
(8925, 1)
(8965, 1)
(9038, 1)
(9048, 1)
(9090, 1)
(9118, 1)
(9123, 1)
(9133, 1)
(9186, 1)
(9194, 1)
(9215, 1)
(9224, 1)
(9229, 1)
(9270, 1)
(9276, 1)
(9278, 1)
(9288, 1)
(9330, 1)
(9332, 1)
(9342, 1)
(9353, 1)
(9359, 1)
(9371, 1)
(9384, 1)
(9391, 1)
(9463, 1)
(9479, 1)
(9514, 1)
(9518, 1)
(9555, 1)
(9567, 1)
(9573, 1)
(9582, 1)
(9585, 1)
(9589, 1)
(9618, 1)
(9657, 1)
(9666, 1)
(9672, 1)
(9681, 1)
(9692, 1)
(9772, 1)
(9809, 1)
(9811, 1)
(9823, 1)
(9834, 1)
(9881, 1)
(9883, 1)
(9896, 1)
(9908, 1)
(9914, 1)
(9917, 1)
(9922, 1)
(9952, 1)
(9970, 1)
(10012, 1)
(10035, 1)
(10045, 1)
(10057, 1)
(10082, 2)
(10097, 1)
(10099, 1)
(10103, 1)
(10116, 1)
(10158, 1)
(10224, 1)
(10261, 1)
(10274, 1)
(10279, 1)
(10295, 1)
(10302, 1)
(10309, 1)
(10317, 1)
(10383, 2)
(10452, 1)
(10473, 1)
(10514, 1)
(10527, 1)
(10532, 1)
(10546, 1)
(10583, 1)
(10609, 1)
(10628, 1)
(10640, 1)
(10657, 1)
(10660, 1)
(10671, 1)
(10691, 1)
(10703, 1)
(10725, 1)
(10729, 1)
(10730, 1)
(10756, 1)
(10758, 1)
(10826, 1)
(10830, 1)
(10835, 1)
(10902, 1)
(10904, 1)
(10908, 1)
(10913, 1)
(10959, 1)
(11076, 1)
(11087, 1)
(11117, 1)
(11150, 1)
(11219, 1)
(11251, 1)
(11266, 1)
(11269, 1)
(11281, 1)
(11302, 1)
(11309, 1)
(11329, 1)
(11332, 1)
(11333, 1)
(11344, 1)
(11347, 1)
(11348, 1)
(11349, 2)
(11372, 1)
(11393, 1)
(11410, 1)
(11420, 1)
(11426, 1)
(11427, 1)
(11435, 1)
(11442, 1)
(11446, 1)
(11466, 1)
(11476, 1)
(11485, 1)
(11488, 1)
(11515, 1)
(11533, 1)
(11534, 1)
(11540, 1)
(11548, 1)
(11551, 1)
(11579, 1)
(11591, 1)
(11595, 1)
(11597, 1)
(11618, 1)
(11634, 1)
(11651, 1)
(11659, 1)
(11692, 1)
(11711, 1)
(11712, 1)
(11721, 1)
(11728, 1)
(11729, 1)
(11766, 1)
(11772, 1)
(11776, 1)
(11781, 1)
(11798, 1)
(11799, 1)
(11801, 1)
(11830, 1)
(11834, 1)
(11863, 1)
(11883, 1)
(11909, 1)
(11910, 1)
(11920, 1)
(11923, 1)
(11930, 1)
(11937, 1)
(11946, 1)
(11954, 1)
(11962, 1)
(11970, 1)
(11982, 1)
(11983, 1)
(12015, 1)
(12017, 1)
(12024, 1)
(12027, 1)
(12036, 1)
(12037, 1)
(12054, 1)
(12058, 1)
(12062, 1)
(12092, 1)
(12093, 1)
(12097, 1)
(12098, 1)

Stimmzettel

Liquid Feedback benutzt bei der Abstimmung eine sogenannte Präferenzwahl. Dabei können neben der Zustimmung und Ablehnung der zur Abstimmung stehenden Initiativen Präferenzen zum Ausdruck gebracht werden (Favorit, erster Ersatzwunsch, …).

Die Abstimmungen im Liquid Feedback sind öffentlich. Im folgenden stellt jede Zeile einen abgegebenen Stimmzettel dar. Die farbig hinterlegten Zahlen geben die gewünschte Reihenfolge der Initiativen wieder: Initiativen mit einer höheren Zahl werden gegenüber Initiativen mit einer geringeren Zahl bevorzugt. Initiativen mit gleicher Zahl sind nicht geordnet. Grüne Zahlen entsprechen Zustimmung, rote Zahlen entsprechen Ablehnung.

  • -1 3531, 3584×123
  • -1 3584 -2 3531×103
  • 2 3584 1 3531×98
  • 1 3531 -1 3584×81
  • 1 3531 0 3584×64
  • 1 3584 -1 3531×59
  • -1 3584, 3531×53
  • 2 3531 1 3584×48
  • 1 3584 0 3531×27
  • 0 3584 -1 3531×25
  • -1 3531 -2 3584×22
  • 0 3531, 3584×16
  • 1 3531, 3584×10
  • 1 3584, 3531×4
  • 0 3531 -1 3584×4
  • 0 3584, 3531×2

Wie beschrieben wurden Stimmen entsprechend des Stimmgewichtes durch eingehende Delegationen wiederholt. Um Platz zu sparen, wird jeder unterschiedliche Wahlzettel nur einmal angezeigt - der Wert am Ende der Zeile gibt an, wie viele gleich ausgefüllt Wahlzettel es gibt.

Der Wert der bunt hinterlegten Zahlen wird im folgenden nur für die Reihenfolge verwendet – die Höhe spielt dabei nur innerhalb eines Stimmzettel eine Rolle. Weiterhin ist es nicht möglich, „Lücken“ in den Werten zu haben und beispielsweise den Wert 3 ohne den Wert 2 zu vergeben.

Hinweis Es wurden weiterhin 210 Stimmen für nicht zugelassene Initiativen abgegeben. Diese werden im folgenden ignoriert.
SELECT initiative_id, grade FROM vote WHERE (issue_id = 1989 AND member_id = ___) ORDER BY grade DESC
vote
Manual and delegated votes without abstentions; Frontends must ensure that no votes are added modified or removed when the issue has been closed.

Hinweis: Das Feld member_id wurde ausgeblendet.

(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -2)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3531, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -2)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -2)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -2)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -2)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -2)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -2)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 0)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -2)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -2)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -2)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 0)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 0)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 0)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -2)
(3531, 0)
(3584, 0)
(3584, 2)
(3531, 1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3531, -1)
(3584, -1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, -1)
(3531, 1)
(3584, 1)
(3531, 2)
(3584, 1)

Präferenzen

Durch die Abstimmungen wurden insgesamt 531 explizite und 1322 implizite Präferenzen abgegeben. Eine explizite Präferenz ist dabei eine vom Mitglied ausgedrückte Reihenfolge zwischen zwei Initiativen. Weiterhin wird aus jedem Stimmzettel errechnet, welche Initiativen gegenüber dem Status Quo bevorzugt werden (d.h. mit einer positiven Zahl bewertet werden) bzw. welche abgelehnt werden (d.h. mit einer negativen Zahl bewertet werden). Diese impliziten Präferenzen werden später dazu verwendet zu entscheiden, ob eine Initiative angenommen oder abgelehnt wird.

Präferenztabelle

Die folgende Tabelle fasst alle Präferenzen zusammen. Jeder Eintrag gibt an, wie viele Mitglieder die Initiative der jeweiligen Zeile der Initiative der jeweiligen Spalte bevorzugen. Grün hinterlegte Zellen beschreiben eine mehrheitliche Zustimmung der Initiative in der jeweiligen Zeile verglichen mit der Initiative in der jeweiligen Spalte. Rot hinterlegte Zellen beschreiben eine mehrheitliche Ablehnungen der Initiative in der jeweiligen Zeile verglichen mit der Initiative in der jeweiligen Spalte.

>V 3531 3584 SQ
3531 219 305
3584 312 246
SQ 385 386

Der Eintrag „SQ“ steht für den Status Quo, der wie eine virtuelle Initiative behandelt wird, die nur mit den impliziten Präferenzen bewertet wird. Wenn ein Mitglied einer Initiative zustimmt, präferiert es diese Initiative gegenüber dem Status Quo. Wenn ein Mitglied hingegen eine Initiative ablehnt, präferiert er den Status Quo gegenüber dieser Initiative. Demnach entspricht die letzte Zeile der Tabelle der Anzahl der Ablehnungen für jede Initiative und die letzte Spalte der Tabelle die Anzahl der Zustimmungen für jede Initiative. Details sind auf dieser Seite beschrieben.

Grafische Darstellung

Die Grafik interpretiert die Tabelle wie folgt: Jeder Kreis entspricht einer Initiative und jeder Pfeil gibt an, wie viele Mitglieder die eine oder die andere Initiative im direkten Vergleich bevorzugen. Die Richtung des Pfeiles stellt eine Mehrheit im direkten Vergleich dar. Bei Gleichstand wird eine Linie ohne Pfeilspitze gezogen. Die Linien sind mit den Präferenzen beschriftet.

Hinweis: Diese Grafik ist nur eine andere Darstellung der Präferenztabelle und gibt lediglich direkte Vergliche, jedoch keine allgemeine Ordnung zwischen Initiativen wieder.

Explizite Präferenzen

  1. 3584 >V 3531
  2. 3531 >V 3584
  3. 3531 >V 3584
  4. 3531 >V 3584
  5. 3584 >V 3531
  6. 3531 >V 3584
  7. 3531 >V 3584
  8. 3584 >V 3531
  9. 3531 >V 3584
  10. 3531 >V 3584
  11. 3531 >V 3584
  12. 3584 >V 3531
  13. 3584 >V 3531
  14. 3584 >V 3531
  15. 3584 >V 3531
  16. 3584 >V 3531
  17. 3584 >V 3531
  18. 3584 >V 3531
  19. 3584 >V 3531
  20. 3531 >V 3584
  21. 3531 >V 3584
  22. 3584 >V 3531
  23. 3584 >V 3531
  24. 3584 >V 3531
  25. 3584 >V 3531
  26. 3531 >V 3584
  27. 3584 >V 3531
  28. 3584 >V 3531
  29. 3531 >V 3584
  30. 3584 >V 3531
  31. 3531 >V 3584
  32. 3584 >V 3531
  33. 3531 >V 3584
  34. 3531 >V 3584
  35. 3531 >V 3584
  36. 3531 >V 3584
  37. 3584 >V 3531
  38. 3531 >V 3584
  39. 3531 >V 3584
  40. 3531 >V 3584
  41. 3584 >V 3531
  42. 3584 >V 3531
  43. 3584 >V 3531
  44. 3531 >V 3584
  45. 3584 >V 3531
  46. 3531 >V 3584
  47. 3584 >V 3531
  48. 3584 >V 3531
  49. 3584 >V 3531
  50. 3584 >V 3531
  51. 3531 >V 3584
  52. 3584 >V 3531
  53. 3584 >V 3531
  54. 3584 >V 3531
  55. 3584 >V 3531
  56. 3584 >V 3531
  57. 3584 >V 3531
  58. 3584 >V 3531
  59. 3584 >V 3531
  60. 3584 >V 3531
  61. 3584 >V 3531
  62. 3584 >V 3531
  63. 3584 >V 3531
  64. 3584 >V 3531
  65. 3584 >V 3531
  66. 3584 >V 3531
  67. 3584 >V 3531
  68. 3584 >V 3531
  69. 3584 >V 3531
  70. 3584 >V 3531
  71. 3584 >V 3531
  72. 3584 >V 3531
  73. 3584 >V 3531
  74. 3584 >V 3531
  75. 3584 >V 3531
  76. 3584 >V 3531
  77. 3584 >V 3531
  78. 3584 >V 3531
  79. 3584 >V 3531
  80. 3584 >V 3531
  81. 3584 >V 3531
  82. 3584 >V 3531
  83. 3584 >V 3531
  84. 3584 >V 3531
  85. 3531 >V 3584
  86. 3531 >V 3584
  87. 3531 >V 3584
  88. 3531 >V 3584
  89. 3531 >V 3584
  90. 3531 >V 3584
  91. 3531 >V 3584
  92. 3531 >V 3584
  93. 3531 >V 3584
  94. 3584 >V 3531
  95. 3584 >V 3531
  96. 3531 >V 3584
  97. 3531 >V 3584
  98. 3531 >V 3584
  99. 3584 >V 3531
  100. 3531 >V 3584
  101. 3531 >V 3584
  102. 3584 >V 3531
  103. 3531 >V 3584
  104. 3531 >V 3584
  105. 3584 >V 3531
  106. 3531 >V 3584
  107. 3531 >V 3584
  108. 3531 >V 3584
  109. 3584 >V 3531
  110. 3584 >V 3531
  111. 3531 >V 3584
  112. 3584 >V 3531
  113. 3531 >V 3584
  114. 3531 >V 3584
  115. 3531 >V 3584
  116. 3531 >V 3584
  117. 3531 >V 3584
  118. 3531 >V 3584
  119. 3531 >V 3584
  120. 3531 >V 3584
  121. 3531 >V 3584
  122. 3531 >V 3584
  123. 3531 >V 3584
  124. 3531 >V 3584
  125. 3531 >V 3584
  126. 3531 >V 3584
  127. 3531 >V 3584
  128. 3531 >V 3584
  129. 3584 >V 3531
  130. 3584 >V 3531
  131. 3584 >V 3531
  132. 3531 >V 3584
  133. 3584 >V 3531
  134. 3584 >V 3531
  135. 3531 >V 3584
  136. 3584 >V 3531
  137. 3531 >V 3584
  138. 3584 >V 3531
  139. 3584 >V 3531
  140. 3584 >V 3531
  141. 3584 >V 3531
  142. 3584 >V 3531
  143. 3531 >V 3584
  144. 3584 >V 3531
  145. 3584 >V 3531
  146. 3531 >V 3584
  147. 3584 >V 3531
  148. 3584 >V 3531
  149. 3584 >V 3531
  150. 3584 >V 3531
  151. 3584 >V 3531
  152. 3584 >V 3531
  153. 3584 >V 3531
  154. 3584 >V 3531
  155. 3584 >V 3531
  156. 3584 >V 3531
  157. 3584 >V 3531
  158. 3584 >V 3531
  159. 3584 >V 3531
  160. 3584 >V 3531
  161. 3584 >V 3531
  162. 3584 >V 3531
  163. 3584 >V 3531
  164. 3584 >V 3531
  165. 3584 >V 3531
  166. 3584 >V 3531
  167. 3584 >V 3531
  168. 3584 >V 3531
  169. 3584 >V 3531
  170. 3584 >V 3531
  171. 3584 >V 3531
  172. 3584 >V 3531
  173. 3584 >V 3531
  174. 3584 >V 3531
  175. 3584 >V 3531
  176. 3584 >V 3531
  177. 3584 >V 3531
  178. 3584 >V 3531
  179. 3584 >V 3531
  180. 3584 >V 3531
  181. 3584 >V 3531
  182. 3584 >V 3531
  183. 3584 >V 3531
  184. 3584 >V 3531
  185. 3584 >V 3531
  186. 3584 >V 3531
  187. 3584 >V 3531
  188. 3584 >V 3531
  189. 3584 >V 3531
  190. 3584 >V 3531
  191. 3584 >V 3531
  192. 3584 >V 3531
  193. 3584 >V 3531
  194. 3584 >V 3531
  195. 3584 >V 3531
  196. 3584 >V 3531
  197. 3584 >V 3531
  198. 3584 >V 3531
  199. 3584 >V 3531
  200. 3584 >V 3531
  201. 3584 >V 3531
  202. 3584 >V 3531
  203. 3584 >V 3531
  204. 3584 >V 3531
  205. 3584 >V 3531
  206. 3584 >V 3531
  207. 3584 >V 3531
  208. 3584 >V 3531
  209. 3584 >V 3531
  210. 3584 >V 3531
  211. 3584 >V 3531
  212. 3584 >V 3531
  213. 3584 >V 3531
  214. 3584 >V 3531
  215. 3584 >V 3531
  216. 3531 >V 3584
  217. 3584 >V 3531
  218. 3584 >V 3531
  219. 3531 >V 3584
  220. 3531 >V 3584
  221. 3584 >V 3531
  222. 3584 >V 3531
  223. 3584 >V 3531
  224. 3584 >V 3531
  225. 3584 >V 3531
  226. 3584 >V 3531
  227. 3584 >V 3531
  228. 3531 >V 3584
  229. 3584 >V 3531
  230. 3531 >V 3584
  231. 3584 >V 3531
  232. 3531 >V 3584
  233. 3531 >V 3584
  234. 3584 >V 3531
  235. 3531 >V 3584
  236. 3531 >V 3584
  237. 3531 >V 3584
  238. 3531 >V 3584
  239. 3531 >V 3584
  240. 3531 >V 3584
  241. 3531 >V 3584
  242. 3584 >V 3531
  243. 3584 >V 3531
  244. 3584 >V 3531
  245. 3584 >V 3531
  246. 3531 >V 3584
  247. 3531 >V 3584
  248. 3531 >V 3584
  249. 3531 >V 3584
  250. 3584 >V 3531
  251. 3584 >V 3531
  252. 3584 >V 3531
  253. 3584 >V 3531
  254. 3584 >V 3531
  255. 3584 >V 3531
  256. 3584 >V 3531
  257. 3584 >V 3531
  258. 3584 >V 3531
  259. 3584 >V 3531
  260. 3584 >V 3531
  261. 3584 >V 3531
  262. 3531 >V 3584
  263. 3531 >V 3584
  264. 3584 >V 3531
  265. 3584 >V 3531
  266. 3584 >V 3531
  267. 3584 >V 3531
  268. 3584 >V 3531
  269. 3584 >V 3531
  270. 3584 >V 3531
  271. 3531 >V 3584
  272. 3584 >V 3531
  273. 3584 >V 3531
  274. 3584 >V 3531
  275. 3531 >V 3584
  276. 3531 >V 3584
  277. 3584 >V 3531
  278. 3531 >V 3584
  279. 3531 >V 3584
  280. 3531 >V 3584
  281. 3531 >V 3584
  282. 3584 >V 3531
  283. 3584 >V 3531
  284. 3584 >V 3531
  285. 3531 >V 3584
  286. 3531 >V 3584
  287. 3531 >V 3584
  288. 3584 >V 3531
  289. 3531 >V 3584
  290. 3531 >V 3584
  291. 3584 >V 3531
  292. 3584 >V 3531
  293. 3531 >V 3584
  294. 3531 >V 3584
  295. 3584 >V 3531
  296. 3584 >V 3531
  297. 3584 >V 3531
  298. 3584 >V 3531
  299. 3584 >V 3531
  300. 3531 >V 3584
  301. 3584 >V 3531
  302. 3531 >V 3584
  303. 3584 >V 3531
  304. 3531 >V 3584
  305. 3584 >V 3531
  306. 3584 >V 3531
  307. 3584 >V 3531
  308. 3584 >V 3531
  309. 3531 >V 3584
  310. 3584 >V 3531
  311. 3584 >V 3531
  312. 3584 >V 3531
  313. 3584 >V 3531
  314. 3531 >V 3584
  315. 3531 >V 3584
  316. 3584 >V 3531
  317. 3584 >V 3531
  318. 3531 >V 3584
  319. 3584 >V 3531
  320. 3531 >V 3584
  321. 3584 >V 3531
  322. 3531 >V 3584
  323. 3584 >V 3531
  324. 3531 >V 3584
  325. 3531 >V 3584
  326. 3584 >V 3531
  327. 3531 >V 3584
  328. 3584 >V 3531
  329. 3531 >V 3584
  330. 3584 >V 3531
  331. 3584 >V 3531
  332. 3584 >V 3531
  333. 3531 >V 3584
  334. 3531 >V 3584
  335. 3584 >V 3531
  336. 3584 >V 3531
  337. 3584 >V 3531
  338. 3584 >V 3531
  339. 3531 >V 3584
  340. 3584 >V 3531
  341. 3531 >V 3584
  342. 3531 >V 3584
  343. 3584 >V 3531
  344. 3531 >V 3584
  345. 3531 >V 3584
  346. 3531 >V 3584
  347. 3531 >V 3584
  348. 3584 >V 3531
  349. 3531 >V 3584
  350. 3531 >V 3584
  351. 3531 >V 3584
  352. 3531 >V 3584
  353. 3584 >V 3531
  354. 3531 >V 3584
  355. 3531 >V 3584
  356. 3531 >V 3584
  357. 3584 >V 3531
  358. 3584 >V 3531
  359. 3584 >V 3531
  360. 3584 >V 3531
  361. 3584 >V 3531
  362. 3584 >V 3531
  363. 3584 >V 3531
  364. 3584 >V 3531
  365. 3531 >V 3584
  366. 3584 >V 3531
  367. 3584 >V 3531
  368. 3584 >V 3531
  369. 3584 >V 3531
  370. 3531 >V 3584
  371. 3584 >V 3531
  372. 3584 >V 3531
  373. 3584 >V 3531
  374. 3584 >V 3531
  375. 3584 >V 3531
  376. 3584 >V 3531
  377. 3584 >V 3531
  378. 3584 >V 3531
  379. 3584 >V 3531
  380. 3584 >V 3531
  381. 3584 >V 3531
  382. 3584 >V 3531
  383. 3584 >V 3531
  384. 3531 >V 3584
  385. 3531 >V 3584
  386. 3531 >V 3584
  387. 3531 >V 3584
  388. 3531 >V 3584
  389. 3531 >V 3584
  390. 3531 >V 3584
  391. 3531 >V 3584
  392. 3531 >V 3584
  393. 3531 >V 3584
  394. 3531 >V 3584
  395. 3531 >V 3584
  396. 3531 >V 3584
  397. 3531 >V 3584
  398. 3531 >V 3584
  399. 3531 >V 3584
  400. 3531 >V 3584
  401. 3531 >V 3584
  402. 3531 >V 3584
  403. 3531 >V 3584
  404. 3531 >V 3584
  405. 3531 >V 3584
  406. 3531 >V 3584
  407. 3531 >V 3584
  408. 3531 >V 3584
  409. 3531 >V 3584
  410. 3531 >V 3584
  411. 3531 >V 3584
  412. 3531 >V 3584
  413. 3531 >V 3584
  414. 3531 >V 3584
  415. 3531 >V 3584
  416. 3531 >V 3584
  417. 3531 >V 3584
  418. 3531 >V 3584
  419. 3531 >V 3584
  420. 3531 >V 3584
  421. 3584 >V 3531
  422. 3584 >V 3531
  423. 3531 >V 3584
  424. 3531 >V 3584
  425. 3531 >V 3584
  426. 3584 >V 3531
  427. 3531 >V 3584
  428. 3584 >V 3531
  429. 3584 >V 3531
  430. 3584 >V 3531
  431. 3531 >V 3584
  432. 3531 >V 3584
  433. 3584 >V 3531
  434. 3584 >V 3531
  435. 3584 >V 3531
  436. 3584 >V 3531
  437. 3584 >V 3531
  438. 3584 >V 3531
  439. 3531 >V 3584
  440. 3584 >V 3531
  441. 3531 >V 3584
  442. 3531 >V 3584
  443. 3584 >V 3531
  444. 3584 >V 3531
  445. 3531 >V 3584
  446. 3584 >V 3531
  447. 3531 >V 3584
  448. 3584 >V 3531
  449. 3531 >V 3584
  450. 3584 >V 3531
  451. 3584 >V 3531
  452. 3531 >V 3584
  453. 3531 >V 3584
  454. 3584 >V 3531
  455. 3531 >V 3584
  456. 3584 >V 3531
  457. 3531 >V 3584
  458. 3584 >V 3531
  459. 3584 >V 3531
  460. 3584 >V 3531
  461. 3584 >V 3531
  462. 3584 >V 3531
  463. 3531 >V 3584
  464. 3531 >V 3584
  465. 3531 >V 3584
  466. 3531 >V 3584
  467. 3531 >V 3584
  468. 3531 >V 3584
  469. 3531 >V 3584
  470. 3584 >V 3531
  471. 3531 >V 3584
  472. 3531 >V 3584
  473. 3531 >V 3584
  474. 3531 >V 3584
  475. 3531 >V 3584
  476. 3531 >V 3584
  477. 3531 >V 3584
  478. 3531 >V 3584
  479. 3531 >V 3584
  480. 3531 >V 3584
  481. 3531 >V 3584
  482. 3584 >V 3531
  483. 3584 >V 3531
  484. 3531 >V 3584
  485. 3531 >V 3584
  486. 3584 >V 3531
  487. 3531 >V 3584
  488. 3531 >V 3584
  489. 3584 >V 3531
  490. 3584 >V 3531
  491. 3584 >V 3531
  492. 3584 >V 3531
  493. 3584 >V 3531
  494. 3531 >V 3584
  495. 3531 >V 3584
  496. 3584 >V 3531
  497. 3584 >V 3531
  498. 3584 >V 3531
  499. 3531 >V 3584
  500. 3584 >V 3531
  501. 3584 >V 3531
  502. 3531 >V 3584
  503. 3531 >V 3584
  504. 3584 >V 3531
  505. 3584 >V 3531
  506. 3584 >V 3531
  507. 3531 >V 3584
  508. 3584 >V 3531
  509. 3584 >V 3531
  510. 3531 >V 3584
  511. 3531 >V 3584
  512. 3584 >V 3531
  513. 3584 >V 3531
  514. 3531 >V 3584
  515. 3584 >V 3531
  516. 3584 >V 3531
  517. 3584 >V 3531
  518. 3584 >V 3531
  519. 3531 >V 3584
  520. 3531 >V 3584
  521. 3531 >V 3584
  522. 3531 >V 3584
  523. 3584 >V 3531
  524. 3584 >V 3531
  525. 3584 >V 3531
  526. 3584 >V 3531
  527. 3584 >V 3531
  528. 3584 >V 3531
  529. 3531 >V 3584
  530. 3584 >V 3531
  531. 3531 >V 3584

Implizite Präferenzen gegenüber Status Quo

  1. 3584 >V SQ
  2. 3531 >V SQ
  3. SQ >V 3584
  4. 3531 >V SQ
  5. SQ >V 3531
  6. 3584 >V SQ
  7. SQ >V 3531
  8. SQ >V 3584
  9. 3584 >V SQ
  10. 3531 >V SQ
  11. 3584 >V SQ
  12. 3531 >V SQ
  13. SQ >V 3531
  14. SQ >V 3584
  15. SQ >V 3584
  16. 3531 >V SQ
  17. 3531 >V SQ
  18. 3584 >V SQ
  19. 3531 >V SQ
  20. 3584 >V SQ
  21. 3531 >V SQ
  22. 3584 >V SQ
  23. 3531 >V SQ
  24. 3584 >V SQ
  25. 3531 >V SQ
  26. 3584 >V SQ
  27. 3531 >V SQ
  28. 3584 >V SQ
  29. 3531 >V SQ
  30. 3584 >V SQ
  31. SQ >V 3531
  32. 3584 >V SQ
  33. SQ >V 3531
  34. SQ >V 3584
  35. 3584 >V SQ
  36. 3531 >V SQ
  37. 3531 >V SQ
  38. 3584 >V SQ
  39. 3531 >V SQ
  40. 3584 >V SQ
  41. SQ >V 3531
  42. 3531 >V SQ
  43. 3584 >V SQ
  44. 3531 >V SQ
  45. 3584 >V SQ
  46. 3531 >V SQ
  47. 3584 >V SQ
  48. 3531 >V SQ
  49. 3584 >V SQ
  50. 3531 >V SQ
  51. 3584 >V SQ
  52. 3531 >V SQ
  53. 3584 >V SQ
  54. 3531 >V SQ
  55. 3584 >V SQ
  56. 3531 >V SQ
  57. 3584 >V SQ
  58. 3531 >V SQ
  59. 3584 >V SQ
  60. 3531 >V SQ
  61. 3584 >V SQ
  62. SQ >V 3531
  63. 3584 >V SQ
  64. 3531 >V SQ
  65. 3584 >V SQ
  66. 3531 >V SQ
  67. 3584 >V SQ
  68. SQ >V 3531
  69. 3584 >V SQ
  70. 3531 >V SQ
  71. SQ >V 3584
  72. 3531 >V SQ
  73. 3584 >V SQ
  74. 3531 >V SQ
  75. 3531 >V SQ
  76. 3584 >V SQ
  77. 3531 >V SQ
  78. 3584 >V SQ
  79. 3531 >V SQ
  80. 3584 >V SQ
  81. 3531 >V SQ
  82. 3584 >V SQ
  83. 3531 >V SQ
  84. 3584 >V SQ
  85. 3531 >V SQ
  86. 3584 >V SQ
  87. 3531 >V SQ
  88. 3584 >V SQ
  89. 3531 >V SQ
  90. 3531 >V SQ
  91. SQ >V 3584
  92. 3531 >V SQ
  93. 3531 >V SQ
  94. 3584 >V SQ
  95. 3531 >V SQ
  96. 3584 >V SQ
  97. 3531 >V SQ
  98. 3584 >V SQ
  99. 3531 >V SQ
  100. 3584 >V SQ
  101. 3531 >V SQ
  102. 3584 >V SQ
  103. SQ >V 3584
  104. 3531 >V SQ
  105. SQ >V 3584
  106. 3531 >V SQ
  107. SQ >V 3531
  108. SQ >V 3531
  109. SQ >V 3584
  110. SQ >V 3531
  111. 3584 >V SQ
  112. 3531 >V SQ
  113. SQ >V 3584
  114. 3531 >V SQ
  115. 3531 >V SQ
  116. 3531 >V SQ
  117. 3584 >V SQ
  118. 3584 >V SQ
  119. 3531 >V SQ
  120. 3584 >V SQ
  121. 3531 >V SQ
  122. 3531 >V SQ
  123. 3584 >V SQ
  124. SQ >V 3584
  125. 3531 >V SQ
  126. 3584 >V SQ
  127. SQ >V 3584
  128. 3531 >V SQ
  129. 3531 >V SQ
  130. 3584 >V SQ
  131. 3531 >V SQ
  132. 3584 >V SQ
  133. 3531 >V SQ
  134. 3584 >V SQ
  135. 3531 >V SQ
  136. 3584 >V SQ
  137. 3531 >V SQ
  138. 3584 >V SQ
  139. 3531 >V SQ
  140. 3584 >V SQ
  141. SQ >V 3531
  142. 3584 >V SQ
  143. SQ >V 3531
  144. SQ >V 3584
  145. 3531 >V SQ
  146. 3584 >V SQ
  147. SQ >V 3531
  148. 3531 >V SQ
  149. 3584 >V SQ
  150. 3584 >V SQ
  151. 3531 >V SQ
  152. 3584 >V SQ
  153. 3531 >V SQ
  154. 3531 >V SQ
  155. 3584 >V SQ
  156. SQ >V 3531
  157. SQ >V 3584
  158. SQ >V 3531
  159. 3531 >V SQ
  160. 3584 >V SQ
  161. 3584 >V SQ
  162. 3531 >V SQ
  163. 3531 >V SQ
  164. 3584 >V SQ
  165. 3531 >V SQ
  166. 3584 >V SQ
  167. 3531 >V SQ
  168. 3584 >V SQ
  169. 3531 >V SQ
  170. 3584 >V SQ
  171. 3531 >V SQ
  172. 3584 >V SQ
  173. SQ >V 3584
  174. 3531 >V SQ
  175. 3584 >V SQ
  176. 3531 >V SQ
  177. 3584 >V SQ
  178. SQ >V 3584
  179. SQ >V 3531
  180. 3584 >V SQ
  181. 3531 >V SQ
  182. SQ >V 3531
  183. 3584 >V SQ
  184. SQ >V 3584
  185. 3531 >V SQ
  186. 3584 >V SQ
  187. 3531 >V SQ
  188. 3584 >V SQ
  189. 3531 >V SQ
  190. SQ >V 3531
  191. 3584 >V SQ
  192. SQ >V 3584
  193. 3531 >V SQ
  194. 3584 >V SQ
  195. 3531 >V SQ
  196. SQ >V 3584
  197. SQ >V 3584
  198. 3531 >V SQ
  199. SQ >V 3584
  200. 3531 >V SQ
  201. SQ >V 3531
  202. 3584 >V SQ
  203. 3531 >V SQ
  204. 3584 >V SQ
  205. 3531 >V SQ
  206. 3584 >V SQ
  207. 3531 >V SQ
  208. 3584 >V SQ
  209. 3531 >V SQ
  210. 3584 >V SQ
  211. 3531 >V SQ
  212. 3584 >V SQ
  213. 3531 >V SQ
  214. 3584 >V SQ
  215. 3531 >V SQ
  216. 3584 >V SQ
  217. 3531 >V SQ
  218. 3584 >V SQ
  219. 3531 >V SQ
  220. 3584 >V SQ
  221. 3531 >V SQ
  222. 3584 >V SQ
  223. 3531 >V SQ
  224. 3584 >V SQ
  225. 3531 >V SQ
  226. 3584 >V SQ
  227. 3531 >V SQ
  228. 3584 >V SQ
  229. 3531 >V SQ
  230. 3584 >V SQ
  231. 3531 >V SQ
  232. 3584 >V SQ
  233. 3531 >V SQ
  234. 3584 >V SQ
  235. 3531 >V SQ
  236. 3584 >V SQ
  237. 3531 >V SQ
  238. 3584 >V SQ
  239. 3531 >V SQ
  240. 3584 >V SQ
  241. 3531 >V SQ
  242. 3584 >V SQ
  243. 3531 >V SQ
  244. 3584 >V SQ
  245. 3531 >V SQ
  246. 3584 >V SQ
  247. 3531 >V SQ
  248. 3584 >V SQ
  249. 3531 >V SQ
  250. 3584 >V SQ
  251. 3531 >V SQ
  252. 3584 >V SQ
  253. 3531 >V SQ
  254. 3584 >V SQ
  255. 3531 >V SQ
  256. 3584 >V SQ
  257. 3531 >V SQ
  258. 3584 >V SQ
  259. 3531 >V SQ
  260. 3584 >V SQ
  261. 3531 >V SQ
  262. 3584 >V SQ
  263. 3531 >V SQ
  264. 3584 >V SQ
  265. 3531 >V SQ
  266. 3584 >V SQ
  267. 3531 >V SQ
  268. 3531 >V SQ
  269. 3584 >V SQ
  270. SQ >V 3531
  271. SQ >V 3584
  272. 3531 >V SQ
  273. 3584 >V SQ
  274. SQ >V 3531
  275. SQ >V 3584
  276. SQ >V 3531
  277. 3584 >V SQ
  278. 3531 >V SQ
  279. 3584 >V SQ
  280. 3531 >V SQ
  281. 3584 >V SQ
  282. 3531 >V SQ
  283. 3584 >V SQ
  284. 3531 >V SQ
  285. 3584 >V SQ
  286. 3531 >V SQ
  287. 3584 >V SQ
  288. 3531 >V SQ
  289. 3584 >V SQ
  290. 3531 >V SQ
  291. 3584 >V SQ
  292. 3531 >V SQ
  293. 3584 >V SQ
  294. 3531 >V SQ
  295. 3584 >V SQ
  296. 3531 >V SQ
  297. 3531 >V SQ
  298. 3584 >V SQ
  299. SQ >V 3531
  300. 3584 >V SQ
  301. 3531 >V SQ
  302. 3584 >V SQ
  303. SQ >V 3531
  304. SQ >V 3531
  305. SQ >V 3584
  306. SQ >V 3531
  307. 3584 >V SQ
  308. 3531 >V SQ
  309. SQ >V 3584
  310. 3584 >V SQ
  311. 3531 >V SQ
  312. 3584 >V SQ
  313. 3531 >V SQ
  314. 3584 >V SQ
  315. 3531 >V SQ
  316. 3584 >V SQ
  317. 3531 >V SQ
  318. 3584 >V SQ
  319. 3531 >V SQ
  320. 3584 >V SQ
  321. 3531 >V SQ
  322. 3584 >V SQ
  323. 3531 >V SQ
  324. 3584 >V SQ
  325. 3531 >V SQ
  326. 3584 >V SQ
  327. 3531 >V SQ
  328. 3584 >V SQ
  329. 3531 >V SQ
  330. 3584 >V SQ
  331. SQ >V 3531
  332. 3584 >V SQ
  333. SQ >V 3531
  334. SQ >V 3584
  335. 3531 >V SQ
  336. SQ >V 3531
  337. SQ >V 3584
  338. 3531 >V SQ
  339. 3584 >V SQ
  340. SQ >V 3531
  341. SQ >V 3584
  342. 3531 >V SQ
  343. 3531 >V SQ
  344. 3584 >V SQ
  345. 3531 >V SQ
  346. 3584 >V SQ
  347. 3584 >V SQ
  348. 3531 >V SQ
  349. 3531 >V SQ
  350. 3584 >V SQ
  351. 3584 >V SQ
  352. 3531 >V SQ
  353. SQ >V 3531
  354. 3531 >V SQ
  355. 3584 >V SQ
  356. SQ >V 3531
  357. SQ >V 3584
  358. SQ >V 3531
  359. 3584 >V SQ
  360. 3531 >V SQ
  361. SQ >V 3531
  362. SQ >V 3584
  363. 3531 >V SQ
  364. 3531 >V SQ
  365. 3584 >V SQ
  366. 3531 >V SQ
  367. 3584 >V SQ
  368. SQ >V 3531
  369. SQ >V 3584
  370. SQ >V 3584
  371. SQ >V 3531
  372. 3584 >V SQ
  373. SQ >V 3531
  374. SQ >V 3584
  375. SQ >V 3531
  376. 3584 >V SQ
  377. SQ >V 3531
  378. SQ >V 3584
  379. SQ >V 3531
  380. SQ >V 3531
  381. SQ >V 3531
  382. SQ >V 3531
  383. SQ >V 3531
  384. SQ >V 3531
  385. SQ >V 3531
  386. SQ >V 3531
  387. SQ >V 3531
  388. SQ >V 3531
  389. SQ >V 3531
  390. SQ >V 3531
  391. SQ >V 3584
  392. 3531 >V SQ
  393. 3584 >V SQ
  394. 3531 >V SQ
  395. 3531 >V SQ
  396. 3584 >V SQ
  397. SQ >V 3584
  398. 3531 >V SQ
  399. SQ >V 3584
  400. 3531 >V SQ
  401. SQ >V 3531
  402. SQ >V 3584
  403. 3584 >V SQ
  404. 3531 >V SQ
  405. 3584 >V SQ
  406. 3531 >V SQ
  407. 3584 >V SQ
  408. 3531 >V SQ
  409. SQ >V 3531
  410. SQ >V 3584
  411. SQ >V 3531
  412. 3531 >V SQ
  413. 3584 >V SQ
  414. 3584 >V SQ
  415. 3531 >V SQ
  416. SQ >V 3531
  417. SQ >V 3584
  418. 3531 >V SQ
  419. 3531 >V SQ
  420. 3584 >V SQ
  421. SQ >V 3584
  422. SQ >V 3531
  423. SQ >V 3584
  424. SQ >V 3531
  425. SQ >V 3584
  426. SQ >V 3531
  427. SQ >V 3584
  428. SQ >V 3531
  429. SQ >V 3531
  430. SQ >V 3584
  431. SQ >V 3531
  432. SQ >V 3584
  433. 3531 >V SQ
  434. 3531 >V SQ
  435. 3584 >V SQ
  436. SQ >V 3531
  437. 3584 >V SQ
  438. 3584 >V SQ
  439. 3531 >V SQ
  440. SQ >V 3584
  441. SQ >V 3531
  442. SQ >V 3584
  443. SQ >V 3531
  444. SQ >V 3584
  445. SQ >V 3531
  446. SQ >V 3584
  447. SQ >V 3531
  448. SQ >V 3584
  449. SQ >V 3531
  450. SQ >V 3584
  451. SQ >V 3531
  452. SQ >V 3584
  453. SQ >V 3531
  454. SQ >V 3584
  455. SQ >V 3531
  456. SQ >V 3584
  457. SQ >V 3531
  458. SQ >V 3584
  459. SQ >V 3531
  460. SQ >V 3584
  461. SQ >V 3531
  462. SQ >V 3584
  463. SQ >V 3531
  464. SQ >V 3584
  465. SQ >V 3531
  466. SQ >V 3584
  467. SQ >V 3531
  468. SQ >V 3584
  469. SQ >V 3531
  470. SQ >V 3584
  471. SQ >V 3531
  472. SQ >V 3584
  473. SQ >V 3531
  474. SQ >V 3584
  475. SQ >V 3531
  476. SQ >V 3584
  477. SQ >V 3531
  478. SQ >V 3584
  479. SQ >V 3531
  480. SQ >V 3584
  481. SQ >V 3531
  482. SQ >V 3584
  483. SQ >V 3531
  484. SQ >V 3584
  485. SQ >V 3531
  486. SQ >V 3584
  487. SQ >V 3531
  488. SQ >V 3584
  489. SQ >V 3531
  490. SQ >V 3584
  491. SQ >V 3531
  492. SQ >V 3584
  493. SQ >V 3531
  494. SQ >V 3584
  495. SQ >V 3531
  496. SQ >V 3584
  497. SQ >V 3531
  498. SQ >V 3584
  499. SQ >V 3531
  500. SQ >V 3584
  501. SQ >V 3531
  502. SQ >V 3584
  503. SQ >V 3531
  504. SQ >V 3584
  505. SQ >V 3531
  506. SQ >V 3584
  507. SQ >V 3531
  508. SQ >V 3584
  509. SQ >V 3531
  510. SQ >V 3584
  511. SQ >V 3531
  512. SQ >V 3584
  513. SQ >V 3531
  514. SQ >V 3584
  515. SQ >V 3531
  516. SQ >V 3584
  517. SQ >V 3531
  518. SQ >V 3584
  519. SQ >V 3531
  520. SQ >V 3584
  521. SQ >V 3531
  522. SQ >V 3584
  523. SQ >V 3531
  524. SQ >V 3584
  525. SQ >V 3531
  526. SQ >V 3584
  527. SQ >V 3531
  528. SQ >V 3584
  529. SQ >V 3531
  530. SQ >V 3584
  531. SQ >V 3531
  532. SQ >V 3584
  533. SQ >V 3531
  534. SQ >V 3584
  535. SQ >V 3531
  536. SQ >V 3584
  537. SQ >V 3531
  538. SQ >V 3584
  539. SQ >V 3531
  540. SQ >V 3584
  541. SQ >V 3531
  542. SQ >V 3584
  543. SQ >V 3531
  544. SQ >V 3584
  545. SQ >V 3531
  546. SQ >V 3584
  547. SQ >V 3531
  548. SQ >V 3584
  549. SQ >V 3531
  550. SQ >V 3584
  551. SQ >V 3531
  552. SQ >V 3584
  553. SQ >V 3531
  554. SQ >V 3584
  555. SQ >V 3531
  556. SQ >V 3584
  557. SQ >V 3531
  558. SQ >V 3584
  559. SQ >V 3531
  560. SQ >V 3584
  561. SQ >V 3531
  562. SQ >V 3584
  563. SQ >V 3531
  564. SQ >V 3584
  565. SQ >V 3531
  566. SQ >V 3584
  567. SQ >V 3531
  568. SQ >V 3584
  569. SQ >V 3531
  570. SQ >V 3584
  571. SQ >V 3531
  572. SQ >V 3584
  573. SQ >V 3531
  574. 3584 >V SQ
  575. 3531 >V SQ
  576. 3531 >V SQ
  577. 3584 >V SQ
  578. SQ >V 3531
  579. 3584 >V SQ
  580. 3531 >V SQ
  581. 3584 >V SQ
  582. 3584 >V SQ
  583. 3531 >V SQ
  584. 3531 >V SQ
  585. SQ >V 3584
  586. 3531 >V SQ
  587. 3531 >V SQ
  588. 3584 >V SQ
  589. 3531 >V SQ
  590. 3584 >V SQ
  591. 3531 >V SQ
  592. 3584 >V SQ
  593. 3531 >V SQ
  594. 3584 >V SQ
  595. SQ >V 3531
  596. 3584 >V SQ
  597. SQ >V 3584
  598. 3531 >V SQ
  599. SQ >V 3584
  600. 3531 >V SQ
  601. 3531 >V SQ
  602. 3584 >V SQ
  603. 3584 >V SQ
  604. 3531 >V SQ
  605. 3584 >V SQ
  606. 3531 >V SQ
  607. 3584 >V SQ
  608. 3531 >V SQ
  609. SQ >V 3584
  610. 3531 >V SQ
  611. SQ >V 3584
  612. 3531 >V SQ
  613. 3531 >V SQ
  614. 3584 >V SQ
  615. 3584 >V SQ
  616. 3531 >V SQ
  617. SQ >V 3531
  618. SQ >V 3584
  619. SQ >V 3531
  620. 3584 >V SQ
  621. 3584 >V SQ
  622. 3531 >V SQ
  623. 3531 >V SQ
  624. 3584 >V SQ
  625. SQ >V 3531
  626. SQ >V 3584
  627. SQ >V 3584
  628. SQ >V 3531
  629. SQ >V 3531
  630. SQ >V 3584
  631. 3584 >V SQ
  632. 3531 >V SQ
  633. SQ >V 3531
  634. SQ >V 3584
  635. SQ >V 3531
  636. SQ >V 3531
  637. SQ >V 3584
  638. 3531 >V SQ
  639. 3584 >V SQ
  640. 3584 >V SQ
  641. 3531 >V SQ
  642. 3584 >V SQ
  643. 3531 >V SQ
  644. 3531 >V SQ
  645. 3584 >V SQ
  646. SQ >V 3531
  647. 3584 >V SQ
  648. SQ >V 3531
  649. 3584 >V SQ
  650. SQ >V 3531
  651. 3584 >V SQ
  652. 3584 >V SQ
  653. 3531 >V SQ
  654. 3531 >V SQ
  655. 3584 >V SQ
  656. 3584 >V SQ
  657. 3531 >V SQ
  658. 3584 >V SQ
  659. 3531 >V SQ
  660. SQ >V 3584
  661. SQ >V 3531
  662. 3584 >V SQ
  663. 3531 >V SQ
  664. 3531 >V SQ
  665. 3584 >V SQ
  666. 3584 >V SQ
  667. 3531 >V SQ
  668. SQ >V 3531
  669. 3584 >V SQ
  670. SQ >V 3531
  671. SQ >V 3584
  672. SQ >V 3531
  673. 3531 >V SQ
  674. 3584 >V SQ
  675. 3584 >V SQ
  676. 3531 >V SQ
  677. 3531 >V SQ
  678. 3584 >V SQ
  679. 3531 >V SQ
  680. 3584 >V SQ
  681. 3531 >V SQ
  682. 3584 >V SQ
  683. 3531 >V SQ
  684. 3584 >V SQ
  685. 3531 >V SQ
  686. 3531 >V SQ
  687. 3584 >V SQ
  688. 3584 >V SQ
  689. 3531 >V SQ
  690. 3584 >V SQ
  691. 3531 >V SQ
  692. 3584 >V SQ
  693. 3531 >V SQ
  694. 3584 >V SQ
  695. 3531 >V SQ
  696. 3584 >V SQ
  697. 3531 >V SQ
  698. 3584 >V SQ
  699. 3531 >V SQ
  700. 3584 >V SQ
  701. 3531 >V SQ
  702. SQ >V 3531
  703. 3531 >V SQ
  704. 3584 >V SQ
  705. SQ >V 3531
  706. 3584 >V SQ
  707. 3584 >V SQ
  708. 3531 >V SQ
  709. SQ >V 3584
  710. 3531 >V SQ
  711. SQ >V 3584
  712. 3531 >V SQ
  713. SQ >V 3584
  714. 3531 >V SQ
  715. SQ >V 3584
  716. 3531 >V SQ
  717. SQ >V 3584
  718. 3531 >V SQ
  719. SQ >V 3584
  720. SQ >V 3531
  721. SQ >V 3531
  722. SQ >V 3584
  723. 3584 >V SQ
  724. 3531 >V SQ
  725. 3584 >V SQ
  726. 3531 >V SQ
  727. 3531 >V SQ
  728. 3584 >V SQ
  729. SQ >V 3584
  730. 3531 >V SQ
  731. SQ >V 3531
  732. SQ >V 3584
  733. 3584 >V SQ
  734. 3531 >V SQ
  735. 3584 >V SQ
  736. 3531 >V SQ
  737. SQ >V 3531
  738. SQ >V 3584
  739. 3531 >V SQ
  740. 3584 >V SQ
  741. 3584 >V SQ
  742. 3531 >V SQ
  743. SQ >V 3584
  744. SQ >V 3531
  745. 3584 >V SQ
  746. 3584 >V SQ
  747. 3531 >V SQ
  748. SQ >V 3531
  749. SQ >V 3584
  750. SQ >V 3531
  751. 3584 >V SQ
  752. 3531 >V SQ
  753. SQ >V 3531
  754. 3531 >V SQ
  755. 3584 >V SQ
  756. 3531 >V SQ
  757. 3584 >V SQ
  758. 3584 >V SQ
  759. 3531 >V SQ
  760. 3584 >V SQ
  761. 3531 >V SQ
  762. SQ >V 3584
  763. SQ >V 3531
  764. 3531 >V SQ
  765. 3584 >V SQ
  766. SQ >V 3531
  767. SQ >V 3584
  768. 3531 >V SQ
  769. 3584 >V SQ
  770. SQ >V 3584
  771. SQ >V 3531
  772. 3531 >V SQ
  773. 3584 >V SQ
  774. 3531 >V SQ
  775. 3584 >V SQ
  776. 3531 >V SQ
  777. 3584 >V SQ
  778. SQ >V 3584
  779. SQ >V 3531
  780. 3584 >V SQ
  781. 3531 >V SQ
  782. SQ >V 3531
  783. SQ >V 3584
  784. SQ >V 3531
  785. SQ >V 3584
  786. SQ >V 3584
  787. 3531 >V SQ
  788. SQ >V 3584
  789. 3531 >V SQ
  790. 3584 >V SQ
  791. 3531 >V SQ
  792. SQ >V 3584
  793. 3531 >V SQ
  794. SQ >V 3584
  795. 3531 >V SQ
  796. 3584 >V SQ
  797. 3531 >V SQ
  798. 3584 >V SQ
  799. 3531 >V SQ
  800. SQ >V 3531
  801. 3584 >V SQ
  802. SQ >V 3584
  803. SQ >V 3531
  804. SQ >V 3531
  805. 3584 >V SQ
  806. SQ >V 3584
  807. SQ >V 3531
  808. SQ >V 3531
  809. 3531 >V SQ
  810. SQ >V 3584
  811. 3531 >V SQ
  812. 3584 >V SQ
  813. 3531 >V SQ
  814. 3584 >V SQ
  815. 3531 >V SQ
  816. SQ >V 3584
  817. 3531 >V SQ
  818. 3584 >V SQ
  819. SQ >V 3584
  820. 3531 >V SQ
  821. SQ >V 3584
  822. 3531 >V SQ
  823. SQ >V 3584
  824. 3531 >V SQ
  825. SQ >V 3584
  826. SQ >V 3531
  827. 3531 >V SQ
  828. 3584 >V SQ
  829. SQ >V 3531
  830. SQ >V 3531
  831. 3584 >V SQ
  832. 3531 >V SQ
  833. SQ >V 3584
  834. SQ >V 3531
  835. SQ >V 3531
  836. 3584 >V SQ
  837. SQ >V 3584
  838. 3531 >V SQ
  839. SQ >V 3531
  840. SQ >V 3584
  841. 3531 >V SQ
  842. SQ >V 3531
  843. 3531 >V SQ
  844. 3584 >V SQ
  845. 3531 >V SQ
  846. SQ >V 3531
  847. 3584 >V SQ
  848. SQ >V 3531
  849. 3584 >V SQ
  850. 3531 >V SQ
  851. 3584 >V SQ
  852. 3531 >V SQ
  853. 3584 >V SQ
  854. 3531 >V SQ
  855. 3584 >V SQ
  856. 3531 >V SQ
  857. SQ >V 3531
  858. SQ >V 3531
  859. SQ >V 3584
  860. SQ >V 3584
  861. SQ >V 3531
  862. SQ >V 3531
  863. SQ >V 3584
  864. SQ >V 3584
  865. SQ >V 3531
  866. SQ >V 3584
  867. SQ >V 3531
  868. 3584 >V SQ
  869. 3531 >V SQ
  870. SQ >V 3584
  871. 3531 >V SQ
  872. SQ >V 3531
  873. SQ >V 3531
  874. 3531 >V SQ
  875. 3584 >V SQ
  876. 3531 >V SQ
  877. 3584 >V SQ
  878. SQ >V 3584
  879. SQ >V 3531
  880. 3531 >V SQ
  881. 3531 >V SQ
  882. 3531 >V SQ
  883. 3531 >V SQ
  884. 3584 >V SQ
  885. SQ >V 3531
  886. SQ >V 3584
  887. SQ >V 3584
  888. 3531 >V SQ
  889. 3584 >V SQ
  890. 3531 >V SQ
  891. SQ >V 3531
  892. SQ >V 3584
  893. 3531 >V SQ
  894. 3584 >V SQ
  895. SQ >V 3584
  896. 3531 >V SQ
  897. 3584 >V SQ
  898. 3531 >V SQ
  899. SQ >V 3531
  900. SQ >V 3584
  901. SQ >V 3531
  902. 3584 >V SQ
  903. SQ >V 3531
  904. SQ >V 3584
  905. 3531 >V SQ
  906. 3584 >V SQ
  907. SQ >V 3531
  908. SQ >V 3584
  909. 3531 >V SQ
  910. 3584 >V SQ
  911. SQ >V 3584
  912. 3531 >V SQ
  913. SQ >V 3531
  914. 3584 >V SQ
  915. SQ >V 3531
  916. SQ >V 3531
  917. SQ >V 3584
  918. SQ >V 3531
  919. SQ >V 3584
  920. 3531 >V SQ
  921. SQ >V 3531
  922. SQ >V 3531
  923. SQ >V 3531
  924. 3584 >V SQ
  925. 3531 >V SQ
  926. 3584 >V SQ
  927. 3531 >V SQ
  928. SQ >V 3584
  929. 3531 >V SQ
  930. 3584 >V SQ
  931. 3531 >V SQ
  932. SQ >V 3584
  933. 3531 >V SQ
  934. SQ >V 3584
  935. SQ >V 3531
  936. 3531 >V SQ
  937. SQ >V 3584
  938. SQ >V 3531
  939. 3531 >V SQ
  940. 3584 >V SQ
  941. 3584 >V SQ
  942. 3531 >V SQ
  943. SQ >V 3531
  944. SQ >V 3584
  945. SQ >V 3531
  946. 3584 >V SQ
  947. SQ >V 3584
  948. 3531 >V SQ
  949. SQ >V 3584
  950. 3531 >V SQ
  951. 3584 >V SQ
  952. 3531 >V SQ
  953. SQ >V 3584
  954. SQ >V 3531
  955. SQ >V 3584
  956. SQ >V 3584
  957. SQ >V 3584
  958. SQ >V 3584
  959. SQ >V 3584
  960. SQ >V 3584
  961. SQ >V 3584
  962. SQ >V 3584
  963. SQ >V 3584
  964. SQ >V 3584
  965. SQ >V 3584
  966. SQ >V 3584
  967. SQ >V 3584
  968. 3531 >V SQ
  969. 3584 >V SQ
  970. 3531 >V SQ
  971. 3584 >V SQ
  972. 3531 >V SQ
  973. 3584 >V SQ
  974. SQ >V 3531
  975. 3584 >V SQ
  976. SQ >V 3531
  977. 3584 >V SQ
  978. SQ >V 3531
  979. 3584 >V SQ
  980. SQ >V 3531
  981. 3584 >V SQ
  982. SQ >V 3531
  983. 3584 >V SQ
  984. SQ >V 3531
  985. 3584 >V SQ
  986. SQ >V 3531
  987. 3584 >V SQ
  988. SQ >V 3531
  989. 3584 >V SQ
  990. SQ >V 3531
  991. 3584 >V SQ
  992. SQ >V 3531
  993. 3584 >V SQ
  994. SQ >V 3531
  995. 3584 >V SQ
  996. SQ >V 3531
  997. 3584 >V SQ
  998. SQ >V 3531
  999. 3584 >V SQ
  1000. SQ >V 3531
  1001. 3584 >V SQ
  1002. SQ >V 3531
  1003. 3584 >V SQ
  1004. SQ >V 3531
  1005. 3584 >V SQ
  1006. SQ >V 3531
  1007. 3584 >V SQ
  1008. SQ >V 3531
  1009. 3584 >V SQ
  1010. SQ >V 3531
  1011. 3584 >V SQ
  1012. SQ >V 3531
  1013. 3584 >V SQ
  1014. SQ >V 3531
  1015. 3584 >V SQ
  1016. SQ >V 3531
  1017. 3584 >V SQ
  1018. SQ >V 3531
  1019. 3584 >V SQ
  1020. SQ >V 3531
  1021. 3584 >V SQ
  1022. SQ >V 3531
  1023. 3584 >V SQ
  1024. SQ >V 3531
  1025. 3584 >V SQ
  1026. SQ >V 3531
  1027. 3584 >V SQ
  1028. SQ >V 3531
  1029. 3584 >V SQ
  1030. SQ >V 3531
  1031. 3584 >V SQ
  1032. SQ >V 3531
  1033. 3584 >V SQ
  1034. SQ >V 3531
  1035. 3584 >V SQ
  1036. SQ >V 3531
  1037. 3584 >V SQ
  1038. SQ >V 3531
  1039. 3584 >V SQ
  1040. SQ >V 3531
  1041. 3584 >V SQ
  1042. SQ >V 3531
  1043. 3584 >V SQ
  1044. SQ >V 3531
  1045. 3584 >V SQ
  1046. SQ >V 3531
  1047. 3584 >V SQ
  1048. 3531 >V SQ
  1049. 3584 >V SQ
  1050. SQ >V 3584
  1051. 3584 >V SQ
  1052. 3531 >V SQ
  1053. SQ >V 3531
  1054. 3584 >V SQ
  1055. 3531 >V SQ
  1056. 3584 >V SQ
  1057. SQ >V 3531
  1058. SQ >V 3584
  1059. 3531 >V SQ
  1060. 3584 >V SQ
  1061. 3531 >V SQ
  1062. 3584 >V SQ
  1063. 3584 >V SQ
  1064. 3531 >V SQ
  1065. 3531 >V SQ
  1066. 3584 >V SQ
  1067. 3531 >V SQ
  1068. SQ >V 3531
  1069. 3584 >V SQ
  1070. 3584 >V SQ
  1071. 3531 >V SQ
  1072. 3531 >V SQ
  1073. SQ >V 3584
  1074. SQ >V 3531
  1075. 3584 >V SQ
  1076. SQ >V 3584
  1077. SQ >V 3531
  1078. 3584 >V SQ
  1079. 3531 >V SQ
  1080. SQ >V 3531
  1081. 3584 >V SQ
  1082. SQ >V 3584
  1083. 3531 >V SQ
  1084. 3531 >V SQ
  1085. 3584 >V SQ
  1086. 3531 >V SQ
  1087. 3531 >V SQ
  1088. 3531 >V SQ
  1089. 3531 >V SQ
  1090. 3584 >V SQ
  1091. 3531 >V SQ
  1092. 3584 >V SQ
  1093. 3531 >V SQ
  1094. SQ >V 3531
  1095. 3584 >V SQ
  1096. 3531 >V SQ
  1097. 3531 >V SQ
  1098. 3584 >V SQ
  1099. SQ >V 3531
  1100. SQ >V 3584
  1101. 3531 >V SQ
  1102. 3584 >V SQ
  1103. 3584 >V SQ
  1104. SQ >V 3531
  1105. SQ >V 3584
  1106. 3531 >V SQ
  1107. 3584 >V SQ
  1108. SQ >V 3531
  1109. 3584 >V SQ
  1110. 3531 >V SQ
  1111. 3584 >V SQ
  1112. 3531 >V SQ
  1113. 3531 >V SQ
  1114. 3584 >V SQ
  1115. 3584 >V SQ
  1116. 3531 >V SQ
  1117. SQ >V 3531
  1118. 3584 >V SQ
  1119. SQ >V 3584
  1120. 3531 >V SQ
  1121. SQ >V 3531
  1122. 3584 >V SQ
  1123. 3531 >V SQ
  1124. 3584 >V SQ
  1125. 3531 >V SQ
  1126. SQ >V 3531
  1127. 3584 >V SQ
  1128. 3531 >V SQ
  1129. SQ >V 3584
  1130. SQ >V 3531
  1131. 3531 >V SQ
  1132. 3584 >V SQ
  1133. 3531 >V SQ
  1134. 3584 >V SQ
  1135. 3584 >V SQ
  1136. 3531 >V SQ
  1137. SQ >V 3531
  1138. 3531 >V SQ
  1139. 3584 >V SQ
  1140. SQ >V 3584
  1141. 3531 >V SQ
  1142. SQ >V 3531
  1143. 3584 >V SQ
  1144. 3531 >V SQ
  1145. SQ >V 3584
  1146. SQ >V 3531
  1147. 3584 >V SQ
  1148. 3531 >V SQ
  1149. 3584 >V SQ
  1150. 3531 >V SQ
  1151. 3584 >V SQ
  1152. 3531 >V SQ
  1153. 3584 >V SQ
  1154. 3531 >V SQ
  1155. SQ >V 3584
  1156. SQ >V 3531
  1157. SQ >V 3531
  1158. 3584 >V SQ
  1159. SQ >V 3531
  1160. 3584 >V SQ
  1161. 3531 >V SQ
  1162. SQ >V 3531
  1163. SQ >V 3531
  1164. SQ >V 3531
  1165. SQ >V 3531
  1166. SQ >V 3531
  1167. 3584 >V SQ
  1168. 3584 >V SQ
  1169. 3531 >V SQ
  1170. 3584 >V SQ
  1171. 3531 >V SQ
  1172. SQ >V 3531
  1173. SQ >V 3584
  1174. SQ >V 3531
  1175. SQ >V 3584
  1176. SQ >V 3531
  1177. SQ >V 3584
  1178. SQ >V 3531
  1179. SQ >V 3584
  1180. SQ >V 3531
  1181. SQ >V 3584
  1182. SQ >V 3531
  1183. SQ >V 3584
  1184. SQ >V 3531
  1185. SQ >V 3584
  1186. SQ >V 3531
  1187. SQ >V 3584
  1188. SQ >V 3531
  1189. SQ >V 3584
  1190. SQ >V 3531
  1191. SQ >V 3584
  1192. SQ >V 3531
  1193. SQ >V 3584
  1194. 3584 >V SQ
  1195. 3531 >V SQ
  1196. 3584 >V SQ
  1197. 3531 >V SQ
  1198. SQ >V 3531
  1199. 3531 >V SQ
  1200. 3584 >V SQ
  1201. SQ >V 3531
  1202. 3531 >V SQ
  1203. 3584 >V SQ
  1204. SQ >V 3584
  1205. SQ >V 3531
  1206. 3584 >V SQ
  1207. 3584 >V SQ
  1208. 3531 >V SQ
  1209. SQ >V 3531
  1210. SQ >V 3584
  1211. SQ >V 3531
  1212. 3584 >V SQ
  1213. 3531 >V SQ
  1214. SQ >V 3584
  1215. SQ >V 3584
  1216. 3531 >V SQ
  1217. 3584 >V SQ
  1218. 3531 >V SQ
  1219. 3584 >V SQ
  1220. 3531 >V SQ
  1221. SQ >V 3531
  1222. SQ >V 3531
  1223. 3584 >V SQ
  1224. 3531 >V SQ
  1225. 3584 >V SQ
  1226. 3531 >V SQ
  1227. SQ >V 3584
  1228. SQ >V 3531
  1229. SQ >V 3584
  1230. 3531 >V SQ
  1231. 3584 >V SQ
  1232. 3531 >V SQ
  1233. 3531 >V SQ
  1234. 3584 >V SQ
  1235. SQ >V 3531
  1236. 3584 >V SQ
  1237. SQ >V 3584
  1238. 3531 >V SQ
  1239. 3584 >V SQ
  1240. 3531 >V SQ
  1241. SQ >V 3531
  1242. SQ >V 3584
  1243. SQ >V 3531
  1244. 3584 >V SQ
  1245. 3531 >V SQ
  1246. SQ >V 3531
  1247. SQ >V 3584
  1248. 3584 >V SQ
  1249. 3531 >V SQ
  1250. 3584 >V SQ
  1251. 3531 >V SQ
  1252. 3531 >V SQ
  1253. 3584 >V SQ
  1254. 3531 >V SQ
  1255. 3584 >V SQ
  1256. 3531 >V SQ
  1257. 3584 >V SQ
  1258. 3531 >V SQ
  1259. 3584 >V SQ
  1260. 3584 >V SQ
  1261. 3531 >V SQ
  1262. SQ >V 3584
  1263. SQ >V 3531
  1264. SQ >V 3584
  1265. SQ >V 3584
  1266. 3584 >V SQ
  1267. 3531 >V SQ
  1268. 3531 >V SQ
  1269. 3584 >V SQ
  1270. SQ >V 3531
  1271. 3584 >V SQ
  1272. SQ >V 3584
  1273. SQ >V 3531
  1274. SQ >V 3584
  1275. 3531 >V SQ
  1276. SQ >V 3531
  1277. 3531 >V SQ
  1278. 3584 >V SQ
  1279. 3531 >V SQ
  1280. 3584 >V SQ
  1281. SQ >V 3584
  1282. SQ >V 3531
  1283. SQ >V 3584
  1284. SQ >V 3531
  1285. SQ >V 3584
  1286. SQ >V 3531
  1287. SQ >V 3584
  1288. 3531 >V SQ
  1289. SQ >V 3531
  1290. SQ >V 3531
  1291. 3584 >V SQ
  1292. SQ >V 3531
  1293. SQ >V 3584
  1294. 3584 >V SQ
  1295. 3531 >V SQ
  1296. SQ >V 3531
  1297. SQ >V 3584
  1298. 3531 >V SQ
  1299. SQ >V 3531
  1300. SQ >V 3584
  1301. 3584 >V SQ
  1302. 3531 >V SQ
  1303. 3584 >V SQ
  1304. 3531 >V SQ
  1305. 3584 >V SQ
  1306. 3531 >V SQ
  1307. 3584 >V SQ
  1308. 3531 >V SQ
  1309. SQ >V 3584
  1310. SQ >V 3531
  1311. SQ >V 3531
  1312. 3584 >V SQ
  1313. 3531 >V SQ
  1314. 3584 >V SQ
  1315. 3531 >V SQ
  1316. 3584 >V SQ
  1317. SQ >V 3584
  1318. 3531 >V SQ
  1319. SQ >V 3531
  1320. SQ >V 3584
  1321. SQ >V 3531
  1322. SQ >V 3584

Schulze-Methode

Um aus der Präferenztabelle eine allgemeine Ordnung der Initiativen zu finden wird die Schulze-Methode verwendet. Diese vergleicht nun die Initiativen nicht nur direkt, sondern auch indirekt. Dabei wird davon ausgegangen, dass Präferenzen transitiv sind, d.h. dass ein Mitglied, dass Initiative A gegenüber B präferiert und B gegenüber C, dann auch A gegenüber C präferieren würde.

Die Schulze-Methode ermittelt nun für jeweils zwei Initiativen A und B die höchste Präferenz, indem nicht nur die direkte Verbindung zwischen A und B, sondern auch indirekte Verbindungen zwischen A und C sowie C und B verglichen werden. Das Ergebnis sind dann die sogenannten stärksten Wege.

Tabelle der stärksten Wege

Die folgende Tabelle fasst alle stärksten Wege zusammen. Jeder Eintrag gibt die Stärke des besten Weges zwischen der Initiative der jeweiligen Zeile der Initiative der jeweiligen Spalte an.

PD 3531 3584 SQ
3531 219 305
3584 312 246
SQ 385 386

Werte, die sich gegenüber der Präferenztabelle unterscheiden, sind fett hervorgehoben. Es ist durchaus möglich, dass gerade bei Abstimmungen zwischen wenigen Initiativen diese Tabelle mit der ursprünglichen Präferenztabelle übereinstimmt. In diesem Fall konnte kein besserer Weg zwischen den jeweiligen Initiativen gefunden werden.

Grafische Darstellung

Schulze-Rang

Mithilfe der stärksten Wege kann nun jede Initiative mit jeder anderen verglichen werden. Da es sein kann, dass mehrere Initiativen gleich gut sind, ist das Ergebnis der Schulze-Methode in der Regel Halbordnung. Dies bedeutet, dass es nicht nur mehrere Siegerinitiativen geben kann, sondern auch, dass nur durch zusätzliche Regeln eine feste Reihenfolge zwischen ansonsten gleich guten Initiativen gefunden werden muss.

Grafische Darstellung

Das Ergebnis der Schulze-Methode kann grafisch so aufgefasst werden, dass ein Pfeil zwischen Initiative A und Initiative B bedeutet, dass im Endergebnis Initiative A besser als Initiative B ist:

Die Grafik wurde zur erhöhten Lesbarkeit transitiv reduziert, d.h. das Pfeile, die sich aus anderen Pfeilen ableiten lassen weggelassen wurden. Wenn beispielsweise Initiative A besser ist als Initiative B und C ist und Initiative B wiederum besser ist als Initiative C ist, dann kann der Pfeil zwischen A und C weggelassen werden.

Eine besondere Rolle spielt bei dieser Halbordnung der Status Quo (blau eingezeichnet). Jede Initiative, die nicht besser als der Status Quo ist (in der Grafik rot eingezeichnet), wird im späteren Verfahren der Siegerermittlung automatisch abgelehnt.

Vollständige Rangfolge

Die oben dargestellt Halbordnung kann mithilfe einer topologischen Sortierung in eine vollständige Ordnung überführt werden. Diese Sortierung hat die Eigenschaft, dass alle in der Halbordnung festgelegten Reihenfolgen eigehalten werden, jedoch bisher ungeordnete Initiativen in eine (potenziell willkürliche) Ordnung gebracht werden.

Im konkreten Fall ist die Ordnung eindeutig.

  1. Status Quo
  2. Initiative 3584: Neue Tempolimits auf Straßen
  3. Initiative 3531: Einführung generelles Tempolimit

O = { [SQ,3531] , [3584,3531] , [SQ,3584] }

Annehmen und Ablehnen von Initiativen

Neben den reinen Präferenzen spielen auch weitere Regeln eine Rolle bei der Ermittlung der Abstimmungssieger.

Dieses Thema wurde mit dem Regelwerk Meinungsbild / Beschlussvorlage abgestimmt. In diesem Regelwerk werden Initiativen nur angenommen, wenn

  1. ihr Schulze-Rang besser als der des Status Quo ist und
  2. es mehr Zustimmungen als Ablehnungen gibt.

Falls eines dieser Kriterien verletzt wird, wird die jeweilige Initiativen bei der Ermittlung des Siegers nicht weiter berücksichtigt.

Ergebnisse

  • Initiative 3584: Neue Tempolimits auf Straßen abgelehnt
    • 246 Zustimmungen
    • 386 Ablehnungen
    • 107 Enthaltungen
    • Verhältnis von Zustimmungen und Ablehnungen ist nicht ausreichend
    • Schulze-Rang ist nicht besser als Status Quo
  • Initiative 3531: Einführung generelles Tempolimit abgelehnt
    • 305 Zustimmungen
    • 385 Ablehnungen
    • 49 Enthaltungen
    • Verhältnis von Zustimmungen und Ablehnungen ist nicht ausreichend
    • Schulze-Rang ist nicht besser als Status Quo
SELECT policy_id FROM issue WHERE (id = '1989') ORDER BY id
SELECT name, direct_majority_num, direct_majority_den, direct_majority_strict FROM policy WHERE (id = 4) ORDER BY id
vote
Manual and delegated votes without abstentions; Frontends must ensure that no votes are added modified or removed when the issue has been closed.
policy
Policies for a particular proceeding type (timelimits, quorum)
(4,)
('Meinungsbild / Beschlussvorlage', 1, 2, True)

Gewinner

Entsprechend der Schulze-Methode gibt es folgende Gewinner:

Es gab keinen Gewinner in dieser Abstimmung.